Every coach I know has had the moment. You blow the whistle to bring the group in, and two players are still at the bleachers looking down at a screen. Or you walk into the locker room before practice and the whole team is silent, heads down, scrolling. Nobody is stretching, nobody is talking, and nobody is getting ready to compete.
So what do you do about phones at basketball practice? Some coaches collect them in a bin at the door. Some ignore them and figure it is not worth the fight. Others try to teach players to manage their phones the way adults have to. I have spent a lot of years at the freshman and JV level, and I think this is one of the most practical culture questions a coach can answer before the season starts. Here is how I see both sides, and what I would recommend you do on Monday.
Why Phones at Practice Became a Real Debate
Ten or fifteen years ago, the phone question barely existed in a gym. Now almost every high school player carries one, and for a lot of them it is the first thing they reach for in any quiet moment. Water breaks, the walk from the locker room, the minutes before practice starts, even the bus ride home. That is not a character flaw. It is just the world they live in.
The problem is that practice time is short and attention is the currency of practice. A freshman team might get ninety minutes on the floor, sometimes less if you share the gym. If players are mentally somewhere else for the first ten minutes and during every break, you lose real teaching time. You also lose the small moments where teammates talk to each other, which is where a lot of chemistry gets built.
At the same time, phones are not only a distraction. Parents use them to coordinate rides. Players use them for schedules, film, and team messages. Some kids have a family situation where being reachable matters. A blanket rule that ignores all of that can create problems of its own. That is why reasonable coaches land in very different places on this.
The Case for Collecting Phones
The coaches who collect phones usually have a simple argument. Practice is a protected space, and the easiest way to protect it is to remove the distraction completely. No decisions, no temptation, no gray area.
It Removes the Temptation Entirely
Teenagers are not great at resisting a buzzing phone in their bag. Honestly, most adults are not either. When the phone is in a bin across the gym or locked in a coach’s office, the question goes away. Players stop checking during water breaks because they cannot. Over a few weeks, many of them start to enjoy the break from it.
It Sends a Clear Message About Practice
Collecting phones tells players that practice matters more than whatever is happening online. It is a visible standard, and visible standards are easier to hold. If you are working on creating standards that players actually follow, a phone bin is one of the most concrete ones you can set. Everyone sees it every day.
It Protects Players From Filming and Posting
This one gets overlooked. When phones are out in the gym or locker room, someone eventually records something they should not. A teammate falling, a bad moment, a locker room conversation. Removing phones protects players from each other and protects your program from a problem you never wanted to deal with.
The Case for Ignoring Them
The coaches on the other end are not lazy. Their point is that you pick your battles, and phones may not be the battle worth picking.
Practice Should Be Demanding Enough That Phones Do Not Matter
If practice is moving fast, with short water breaks and constant reps, players do not have time to check anything. The argument goes that a phone problem is really a practice design problem. Tighten the plan, cut the dead time, and the phones take care of themselves. There is some truth here. A well run practice leaves very little room for distraction.
Enforcement Takes Energy
Every rule you make is a rule you have to enforce. If you collect phones, someone has to manage the bin, handle the kid who forgot, deal with the parent who could not reach their child, and keep track of the phone that went missing. For a coaching staff of one or two people, that is real time and attention taken from basketball.
Families Sometimes Need to Reach Players
Rides change. Plans change. Some players are responsible for younger siblings or have something going on at home. Coaches who ignore phones often do it because they do not want a policy that makes a family’s life harder.
The Case for Teaching Players to Manage Them
The middle option is the one that sounds the most reasonable and is the hardest to do well. The idea is that players are going to have phones for the rest of their lives, so the job is to teach them when to put the phone away and when it is fine to have it.
It Builds a Real Life Skill
A college classroom, a job, a team meeting. None of those will have a bin at the door. Players who learn to self regulate at fifteen are better prepared than players who only behave because the phone was taken away. That is a strong argument, and it lines up with the bigger goal of growing young people and not just basketball players.
It Puts Ownership on the Players
When players help set the expectation, they tend to hold each other to it. A team that decides together that phones stay in bags until the final huddle is building accountability the same way you would with effort or communication.
The Weakness Is Consistency
Here is the catch. Teaching players to manage phones only works if the expectations are clear and the coach actually follows through. A vague “be responsible with your phone” turns into ignoring them within two weeks. Freshmen especially need structure before they can handle freedom.
What I Recommend for Freshman and JV Teams
My recommendation is a staged approach. Start with clear structure, then hand over responsibility as players earn it. Younger teams start closer to collection. Older, more mature groups move toward self management. Here is how that can look.
Set a Phone Free Zone and Time
Define exactly when phones are away. For most teams I like this: phones go away when players step on the floor and come back out after the final huddle. That includes water breaks. Be specific about the locker room too. A simple rule like “no phones out in the locker room, ever” protects everyone and is easy to remember.
Use a Bin for the First Few Weeks
For freshman teams especially, start the season with a phone bin or a designated bag spot away from the court. Explain why. You are not punishing anyone. You are protecting practice time and protecting each other. After the first few weeks, if the group is handling it, let players keep phones in their bags with the same expectation. If it slides, the bin comes back. That gives players a reason to own it.
Give Families a Way to Reach You
The easiest way to take the pressure off is to tell parents at the start of the season how to reach the coaching staff during practice in an emergency. Then players do not need to be on their phones for family reasons. Most parents appreciate the clarity, and it removes the main objection to putting phones away.
Make It Part of Your Non Negotiables
Whatever you choose, write it down with your other program expectations and go over it on day one. If you are establishing non negotiables in your program, the phone rule belongs on that list next to being on time and being a good teammate. The consequence should be simple and boring, like losing phone privileges for the week. Nothing dramatic.
Fix the Dead Time in Practice
The coaches who say a tight practice solves the problem are partly right. Look at your plan and find the gaps. Long water breaks, slow transitions between drills, players standing around while you set up the next station. Shrink those, and you will see fewer phones even before you make a rule. If you want ideas, here is a guide on how to plan efficient basketball practices that cuts a lot of that wasted time.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Making a rule you will not enforce. If you say phones are collected and then let it slide when you are busy, players learn your rules are optional. That spills into everything else.
- Using your own phone the whole practice. Players notice. If you are scrolling while they run, the rule feels unfair. Use it for the clock or film and then put it down.
- Turning it into a power struggle. Explain the why, keep the consequence small, and move on. You want players thinking about basketball, not about winning an argument with you.
- Forgetting the bus and locker room. Many phone problems happen outside the gym. Decide your expectations for those spaces too.
Final Thoughts
There is no perfect phone policy, but there is a bad one, and it is the policy nobody understands or enforces. Collecting phones gives you clean structure. Ignoring them saves energy but costs focus. Teaching players to manage them is the best long term goal, but younger players need structure first. For most freshman and JV teams, I would start with a bin, explain why, give families a way to reach the staff, and hand over responsibility once the group shows they can handle it.
If you want help building the rest of your program expectations, along with the playbooks and practice plans I use, take a look at Underdog Hoops University. It is built for coaches at exactly this level.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should coaches collect phones before games too?
Many coaches do, at least from the time players start warming up until the postgame talk is over. Game day is when focus matters most and when the temptation to check messages or social media is highest. A simple rule that phones stay in bags from warmups through the final huddle works for most teams.
What if a parent insists their child needs a phone during practice?
Listen to the reason, because sometimes it is legitimate. In most cases, giving the parent a way to reach the coaching staff directly solves it. If there is a real need, like a medical or family situation, make a quiet exception for that player and explain it to the team only if needed.
Can phones ever help at practice?
Yes. Coaches can use them to film a drill, show a quick clip, or run a timer. The key is that the coach controls when phones are used for basketball. Players having their own phones out during practice is a different thing, and that is where the rule should be clear.
Keep Reading
- Teaching Accountability Without Killing Confidence
- Creating a Player First Culture Without Losing Authority
- How to Build Buy In From Day One
Want the playbooks, practice plans and film breakdowns I use with my own teams? Try Underdog Hoops University free for 14 days.
