Few practice design debates get coaches as fired up as this one. On one side are coaches who built their practices around traditional drills: form shooting, three man weave, closeout lines, shell. On the other are coaches who have shifted toward small-sided games and a constraints-led approach, where players learn by playing 2 on 2, 3 on 3 and 4 on 4 with rules that shape what they practice. Each side thinks the other is missing something important.
I have spent a lot of years at the freshman and JV level, and I have run practices that leaned hard in both directions. I do not think either camp is wrong. I do think most teams need a mix, and that the right ratio depends on where your players are and what time of year it is. Let’s look at both sides fairly and then talk about a practical ratio you can start with on Monday.
The Case for Traditional Drills
Traditional drills have lasted for a reason. They do some things very well.
They Build Clean Technique
When a player is learning how to shoot, finish or defend, isolated reps help. A drill lets you slow the skill down, fix the footwork and get many clean repetitions in a short time. Young players especially need that foundation before they can use the skill under pressure.
They Are Easy to Teach and Coach
Drills are predictable. Everyone knows where to go, what to do and what a good rep looks like. That makes it easier for coaches to see mistakes and give quick corrections. With a big roster and limited assistants, that structure helps keep practice organized.
They Install Team Concepts
Shell drill, transition lanes, press break walk throughs and set plays all need some form of structured, repeated teaching. You cannot learn a help rotation or a baseline out of bounds play from a random 3 on 3 game. Drills give you the framework. Our post on the importance of purposeful drills goes deeper on making each drill earn its spot.
The Downside: Transfer Can Be Weak
The problem is that many drills do not look like games. Players make shots in a line with no defense and then struggle when someone is closing out. They can run a perfect three man weave and still make bad decisions in transition. If drills are too far removed from game situations, the skills do not always carry over.
The Case for Small-Sided Games and Constraints
The small-sided games movement has grown a lot in recent years, and there is good thinking behind it.
Players Learn to Read and React
In a game, players have to see the defense, make a decision and execute under pressure. Small-sided games give them that in every possession. A 3 on 3 game forces players to read help, make the extra pass and recover on defense. Those are decision skills that drills often skip.
More Touches and More Engagement
In a 2 on 2 or 3 on 3 game, every player is involved on every possession. There is no standing in a long line. Players touch the ball more, defend more and compete more. Most kids also enjoy it more, which keeps energy high. For more on how these games build skill and basketball IQ, see small-sided games for skill and IQ development.
Constraints Shape the Lesson
The constraints-led approach uses rules to guide what players practice. Want more ball movement? No dribbling, or every player must touch the ball before a shot. Want better finishing? Layups count double. Want help defense? Offense gets a point for any paint touch. Players learn the skill by solving the problem the game presents.
The Downside: Messy Reps and Hidden Gaps
Small-sided games can get sloppy. Players may repeat bad habits at game speed, and a coach watching three games at once can miss a lot. Young players with weak fundamentals may struggle to succeed at all, which leads to frustration. Without some direct teaching, technique can lag behind.
Why It Is Not Either Or
The best practices I have seen use drills and games together, with each one setting up the other.
Teach, Then Test
A simple model is to teach a skill in a drill, then test it in a small-sided game. Work on closeouts in a short drill, then play 3 on 3 where closeouts are emphasized. The drill builds the habit, and the game shows whether it holds up under pressure.
Use Games to Diagnose
You can also flip it. Play a game first and watch what breaks down. If players keep getting beat off the dribble, pull them into a short defensive drill, then go back to the game. This keeps teaching connected to real problems.
Build Game Elements Into Drills
Many drills can be made more game-like with small changes. Add a defender, add a decision, add scoring or add a time limit. A shooting drill becomes a closeout and shoot drill. A passing drill becomes a 3 on 2 read. Our post on building practice plans that translate to games has more on designing practice blocks that carry over.
My Recommendation: A Practical Ratio
Here is my answer. For most freshman and JV teams, start the season around 60 percent drills and 40 percent small-sided and live games. As the season goes on, shift toward about 40 percent drills and 60 percent games.
Early Season: More Teaching
Early in the season, players need foundation and your team needs to install systems. Lean on drills to teach technique, defense principles and offensive structure. Use small-sided games to reinforce what you taught and keep practice competitive.
Mid to Late Season: More Playing
Once the foundation is in place, shift toward games. Players already know what to do. Now they need to do it under pressure, against live defenders, with decisions to make. Keep short drills for problem areas and for maintaining technique, but let games carry more of the load.
Adjust for Your Group
A group with weaker fundamentals may need a higher drill ratio for longer. A more experienced JV group may be ready for more games sooner. Watch your players and adjust. The ratio is a starting point, not a rule.
What That Looks Like in a Real Practice
Say you have about 100 minutes of active work in a midseason practice. At a 40 and 60 split, roughly 40 minutes goes to drills: a quick ball handling and finishing block, a shooting block with closeouts and a short defensive breakdown tied to your next opponent. The other 60 minutes goes to games: a 2 on 2 advantage game, a constrained 3 on 3 or 4 on 4 that targets your weak spot from the last game, and a live 5 on 5 segment with special situations. Count your minutes after practice once a week. Most coaches are surprised at how far their real ratio drifts from what they intended.
Small-Sided Games to Try This Week
If you want to add more games to practice, here are a few simple ones that work well at the high school level.
- 2 on 2 Advantage: Offense starts with the ball at the wing and a defender recovering from the lane. Teaches attacking a closeout and help recovery.
- 3 on 3 No Dribble: Offense cannot dribble except to drive to the rim. Teaches spacing, cutting and passing.
- 4 on 4 Paint Touch: Offense gets an extra point if the ball touches the paint before a shot. Teaches inside out play and help defense.
- 3 on 3 Stop to Score: Defense must get a stop before they can go on offense. Builds defensive intensity.
- Winner Stays: Teams play to 3, winner stays on. Keeps competition high and players moving.
Keep Games Short and Focused
Run games in short bursts of three to five minutes with a clear focus. Stop briefly to coach a key point, then go again. That keeps quality high and lets you teach without killing the flow.
Final Thoughts
The drills versus small-sided games debate is really a debate about how players learn. Traditional drill coaches are right that technique and structure need direct teaching. Small-sided game coaches are right that players learn decisions and competitiveness by playing. The best practices combine both: teach in drills, test in games and shift the balance toward games as the season goes on.
Start with a simple ratio, watch your players closely and adjust as you go. If you want a quick way to lay out each practice block and track your ratio across the week, try the Underdog Hoops Practice Planner.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are small-sided games in basketball?
Small-sided games are competitive games with fewer players than a full 5 on 5, such as 2 on 2, 3 on 3 or 4 on 4. Coaches often add rules, called constraints, that shape what players practice, like no dribbling or bonus points for paint touches.
Are traditional basketball drills outdated?
No. Drills are still valuable for teaching technique, installing team concepts and fixing specific problems. The key is making drills purposeful and connecting them to game situations so the skills transfer.
How much practice time should be spent on small-sided games?
A good starting point for freshman and JV teams is about 40 percent of practice early in the season, increasing to around 60 percent as the season goes on. Adjust based on your players’ fundamentals and what your team needs to work on.
Keep Reading
- How to Keep Practices Competitive and Fun
- Teaching Multiple Skills in One Drill
- How to Balance Skill Development and Team Concepts
Build your next practice in the Underdog Hoops Practice Planner, and grab full practice plan examples inside Underdog Hoops University (14-day free trial).
